The Pete Alonso Conversation That Steve Cohen and David Stearns Might As Well Be Having
As the New York Mets enter a crucial offseason, the future of their star first baseman Pete Alonso is likely one of the most pressing topics of discussion between owner Steve Cohen and new president of baseball operations David Stearns. Alonso, the face of the Mets’ power-hitting offense and a fan favorite, is approaching free agency after the 2024 season, and the conversation around whether to extend him or explore other options is bound to shape the franchise’s direction for years to come.
The Case for Extending Alonso
In any internal conversation regarding Alonso’s future, his impressive resume speaks for itself. Since making his debut in 2019, Alonso has been one of the most prolific power hitters in Major League Baseball. He set a rookie record with 53 home runs that year and has consistently been among the league leaders in homers and RBIs ever since. His production in the middle of the Mets’ lineup is a cornerstone of the team’s offered
From Cohen’s perspective, Alonso is more than just a power bat. He’s the heart and soul of the Mets, and his connection to the fan base is invaluable. For a franchise that has long been trying to build a winning culture, letting go of such a key figure could send the wrong message to fans and players alike. Alonso’s presence in the clubhouse, leadership qualities, and ability to produce in clutch situations make him a prime candidate for a long-term extension.
Additionally, Alonso’s marketability as a franchise player is significant. From jersey sales to his participation in events like the Home Run Derby, he is a figure that draws attention not just for his talent but also for his personality and charisma. For a big-market team like the Mets, keeping a player who embodies the spirit of the franchise might seem like a no-brainer.
The Case for Caution
However, the conversation between Cohen and Stearns likely also includes the more cautious approach of not rushing into a massive extension. While Alonso is an elite power hitter, his game is not without its limitations. His defensive abilities at first base have been questioned at times, and though he has improved in that area, he’s not a Gold Glove-caliber player. The modern analytics-driven front office might weigh the potential risk of committing long-term to a player who is heavily reliant on his power as he ages.
Another factor in this conversation is Alonso’s projected market value. With teams across MLB increasingly valuing financial flexibility, offering a mega-contract to a slugger entering his late 20s could be risky. The market for power hitters has seen ups and downs, and while Alonso is a top-tier player, the Mets’ front office may debate whether an extension in the range of $200 million or more is worth the long-term commitment.
David Stearns, known for his analytical and strategic mindset, may also be considering whether the Mets’ roster construction can be improved by reallocating resources. The Mets have struggled to find consistent pitching depth and address holes in their lineup. By potentially using Alonso as a trade asset, Stearns could bring in younger talent or key pieces that help rebuild the Mets around a more balanced and sustainable roster.
Steve Cohen’s Influence
Steve Cohen’s role in this discussion is critical. Since purchasing the team, Cohen has made it clear that he wants the Mets to be perennial contenders. He has shown a willingness to spend big, but he has also stressed the importance of building a sustainable winning culture, not just throwing money at problems. Cohen has consistently supported his star players, and he has a strong connection to the team’s fan base, which may put pressure on him to keep Alonso in the fold.
However, Cohen also hired Stearns to bring structure and long-term planning to the franchise. If Stearns advises against a long-term extension or presents a trade scenario that benefits the Mets’ future, Cohen will need to weigh his emotional connection to Alonso against what’s best for the organization’s long-term success.
Trade Rumors and Uncertainty
Throughout the 2023 season, rumors swirled about Alonso’s future. Trade rumors intensified during the Mets’ disappointing year, with reports suggesting the team might consider moving Alonso if they don’t foresee a contract extension working out. While no trade came to fruition, the fact that it was even considered speaks to the complexities of the decision Cohen and Stearns face.
On one hand, trading Alonso now, while his value is still extremely high, could yield a significant return of prospects or established talent. On the other hand, letting go of a homegrown talent who has been the face of the franchise might alienate fans and create more questions than answers for a team looking to compete.
The Verdict: What Should the Mets Do?
The conversation between Steve Cohen and David Stearns is not an easy one, and it will shape the future of the Mets in profound ways. Extending Pete Alonso solidifies a power-hitting cornerstone for years to come, cementing his place in Mets history and keeping a fan favorite at Citi Field. However, it also carries financial risks and might limit roster flexibility moving forward.
Trading Alonso, while painful in the short term, could provide the Mets with the type of return that accelerates a retooling or rebuild, setting the team up for sustained success. It would be a bold move, but it may be what Stearns believes is necessary to turn the Mets into a perennial contender.
In the end, the decision comes down to balancing Alonso’s value as a player and a figurehead with the team’s long-term goals. Whatever the Mets decide, it will be a defining moment in the Steve Cohen-David Stearns era and for the future of the New York Mets.
